Our content is meticulously curated through independent research, testing, reviews, and AI-driven recommendations, all designed to present you with the finest product choices. When you make a purchase through our links, it could result in us earning a commission.

Last Updated:

In the world of kitchen appliances, few hold the same nostalgic charm and everyday utility as the humble toaster. Whether you're a breakfast enthusiast or simply crave a warm slice of bread now and then, choosing the right toaster can make a surprising difference in your daily routine. But with so many options available, from basic models to those equipped with cutting-edge technology, how do you navigate the possibilities?

We evaluated the best of the best out there based on user-friendliness, longevity, innovative features, and setting diversity. In our search, we found the GE Stainless Steel Four-Slice Toaster to be the best overall, boasting 7 different settings, wide slots, and durability. If GE's model doesn't suit your needs, I've included four option high-quality options that cater to a variety of budgets and needs. 

The Best Toaster: Buying Guide

Ever wanted to grab a crisp, golden-brown piece of toast straight from the toaster to kick-start your morning? Rhetorical question — of course you have! After all, who hasn’t?  To make this dream a reality, you’ll need to purchase the right toaster. That's why we've put together this comprehensive buying guide. It’s here to help you pick the best toaster for you and your kitchen. Let’s get started!

Size and capacity

Start your hunt for the best toaster by examining the size and capacity of each model. Some toasters have room for two slices at once while others have a four-slice design. Remember that larger toasters consume more counter space, but they are also twice as efficient as smaller ones.

Energy efficiency

Make sure you assess the energy efficiency of toasters you’re considering. An energy-efficient toaster is one that can heat up quickly while keeping your electricity bills at a reasonable level. We recommend toasters that have high wattage ratings because they heat up fast while providing you with consistent results every time. However, the caveat is that they consume more power than low-wattage toasters. It’s all about finding a balance between performance and energy consumption.

Browning control

Did you know that a feature called browning control is a crucial aspect to consider when shopping for toasters? Imagine biting into a piece of toast that is overdone it tastes like charcoal or so underdone that it’s barely even warm. With an adjustable browning control feature, you can avoid these undesirable extremes. Select a toaster that offers a wide range of browning options for best results.

Extra features

After considering the capacity, efficiency, and browning control of a toaster, take a moment to analyze any other extra features that the toaster offers. From defrosting and reheating to bagel settings and more, bonus features like these can amplify your experience.

Safety

Never overlook the safety features of a toaster when shopping for one. For instance, a cool-touch exterior can prevent accidental burns. Meanwhile, an automatic shut-off feature can protect the toaster from overheating because it will turn itself off if it gets too hot. Similarly, a high-lift lever means you’ll be able to safely eject the contents of the toaster without risking your safety.

Price

The price of a toaster should be a major factor in your decision-making process, but don't let it be the only thing you focus on. At the same time, you don’t want to buy the cheapest toaster on the market just because it’s inexpensive. Such a low price point could indicate low quality. On the other hand, expensive models might be overpriced. It’s also possible that they are equipped with features that you’ll never use, so you’re spending more on something you don’t need in the first place.

Top Picks

  • Best Overall: Ge Stainless Steel Four-Slice Toaster
  • Most Practical: Vintage Black 850-Watt Toaster
  • Most Unique Aesthetic: Buydeem Dt640 Four-Slice Retro Toaster
  • Most Lightweight: Haden Heritage Four-Slice Retro Toaster
  • Most Space-Saving Design: Café Express Two-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster

Reviews

Best Overall
GE Stainless Steel Four-Slice Toaster

Ge Stainless Steel Four-Slice Toaster

Pros Cons
  • Perfect toasting on both sides
  • Wide slots for bagels and breads
  • Easy to clean with removable tray
  • Uneven toasting with single slices
Most Practical
Vintage Black 850-Watt Toaster

Vintage Black 850-Watt Toaster

Pros Cons
  • Wide slots for various bread sizes
  • Easy to clean with crumb tray
  • Includes heat-resistant bamboo tongs
  • Fingerprints show easily
Most Unique Aesthetic
BUYDEEM DT640 Four-Slice Retro Toaster

Buydeem Dt640 Four-Slice Retro Toaster

Pros Cons
  • Wide and long slots
  • Retro design and attractive color
  • Quiet operation with reheat function
  • Initial unpleasant chemical smell
Most Lightweight
Haden Heritage Four-Slice Retro Toaster

Haden Heritage Four-Slice Retro Toaster

Pros Cons
  • Retro design to enhance kitchen decor
  • Even and consistent toasting experience
  • Adjustable settings for customized toast
  • Hard to read numbers on dials
Most Space-Saving Design
Café Express Two-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster

Café Express Two-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster

Pros Cons
  • Sleek and stylish design
  • High-quality toasting abilities
  • Durable and substantial build
  • High price compared to build quality

FAQs

How should I clean my toaster?

Unplug the toaster and let it cool down completely. Then, remove the crumb tray and make sure you empty it. You can also use a dry cloth to wipe down the outside. For the interior of the toaster, use a soft brush and gently clean the inside. Never use water or any other liquids when you're cleaning the inside of your toaster. Otherwise, not only could you cause damage to the electrical components of your toaster but you might put your safety at risk, too.

Why did my toaster start smoking?

Your toaster might start smoking due to a build-up of crumbs or grease that has accumulated on the heating elements of the toaster. To prevent this from happening, clean your toaster regularly. Also, before using your toaster, make sure there aren't any food particles inside your toaster.

Can I use a toaster for foods other than bread?

While toasters are primarily designed for bread, you can use them with bagels, English muffins, and waffles, too. However, never try to toast foods that have fillings inside, frosting on top, or any kind of coating.