Our content is meticulously curated through independent research, testing, reviews, and AI-driven recommendations, all designed to present you with the finest product choices. When you make a purchase through our links, it could result in us earning a commission.

Last Updated:

Mason jars are a staple in many households, but these jars are nothing without accompanying lids. Mason jars wouldn't be able to store and preserve food as well as they do without the proper mason jar lids. Choosing the highest quality airtight lids can make your food last longer while buying poor quality lids will cause food to go bad. The best mason jar lids of 2024 are the solution to reliable food preservation. In this buying guide, we reviewed five mason jar lids that we’d recommend to anyone, starting with our favorite pick, the County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Lid.

 

The Best Mason Jar Lids: Buying Guide

A useful type of food storage container, mason jars are versatile, practical, and incredibly efficient. You can store just about anything in a mason jar, making them some of the most multipurpose storage options on the market. However, a mason jar is only as reliable as its lid.

With such a wide range of lids on the market these days, it can be a bit tricky to know which lids are worth purchasing. But don’t worry! We put this comprehensive guide together to help you navigate the world of mason jar lids. Let’s explore the factors we think you should consider before buying a new mason jar lid.

Material

Mason jar lids are most commonly made of metal or plastic. Metal lids are usually made out of tin, stainless steel, or aluminum. Not only are they highly durable but they are also perfect for canning purposes. They’re often coated with the goal of resisting rust, and they are also dishwasher-safe.

On the other hand, plastic mason jar lids are more suitable for storing dry goods or craft-related tools. They’re typically BPA-free, and they tend to be less prone to denting or rusting than other options. When choosing which mason jar lids you should buy, pick the lid type that is more ideal for your intended purposes.

Size

When it comes to purchasing mason jar lids, size matters. The most common sizes are regular-mouth lids with diameters of 2.75 inches and wide-mouth lids with diameters of 3.38 inches. Regular-mouth lids are suitable for small jars, and that's why they are most commonly used for canning smaller fruits or vegetables.

Alternatively, wide-mouth lids are specifically made for large jars, making them ideal when you're pickling foods or storing larger items. Always ensure that you measure the opening of your jar before buying a lid.

Type

Mason jar lids are available in two main types, including two-piece lids and single-piece lids. Two-piece lids are perfect for canning purposes because they create a vacuum seal, which is necessary for the preservation of food. However, single-piece lids are more convenient for storing everyday items or serving foods shortly after preparing them. Just make sure you opt for the type of lid that caters to your intended uses.

Design

Design is a vital factor to consider when shopping for mason jar lids because the design of the lids will affect both functionality and aesthetics. This ensures that the lid fits securely while simultaneously enhancing the overall look of the jar. Mason jar lids are available in various styles and designs, including classic metal screw-on lids and reusable flip cap lids as well as customized options for specific functions, like pouring, storing, or crafting.

Seal Quality

Seal quality is crucial when purchasing mason jar lids. This is what determines how well the mason jar lids preserve the freshness and flavor of the jar’s content. If canning is your intended use, look for lids with a sealing compound around the inner edges to ensure a reliable vacuum-sealed effect. Now, for storage or decorative purposes, simple lids that don't have a sealing compound are suitable. Plus, they are more cost-effective! 

Durability

Durability is another factor to consider when purchasing mason jar lids specifically for safe and secure storage. Metal lids with a rust-resistant coating are durable. They can also withstand high temperatures during the canning process. Now, although plastic lids are not suitable for canning, they are perfect for keeping goods dry or storing arts and crafts supplies because they are dent- and rust-resistant.

Price

Last but not least, consider the price of mason jar lids before you purchase any. While mason jar lids are generally affordable, the costs can add up if you’re buying them in bulk. Keep in mind that metal lids are usually more expensive than plastic ones due to their durability and canning suitability. Always consider your budget and the number of lids you’ll need before submitting an order.

Top Picks

  • Best Overall: County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Lid
  • Best For Crafts: Arteza Regular Mouth Mason Jar Lid
  • Best For Storage: Ball Mason Jar Lid
  • Best For Organizing: Aozita 16-Pack Plastic Mason Jar Lid
  • Most Durable: Masontops Multi-Top Flip Cap Mason Jar Lid

Reviews

Best Overall
County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Lid

County Line Kitchen Mason Jar Lid

Pros Cons
  • Transforms jars into drinking bottles
  • Lid seals tightly without leaking
  • Comes with a flip cap
  • Lid may be difficult to remove
Best for Crafts
Arteza Regular Mouth Mason Jar Lid

Arteza Regular Mouth Mason Jar Lid

Pros Cons
  • Can paint or draw on lids
  • Reusable and available in two sizes
  • Comes with 24 lids
  • Only compatible with regular-mouth mason jars
Best for Storage
Ball Mason Jar Lid

Ball Mason Jar Lid

Pros Cons
  • Perfect for storing dry goods
  • Comes with six leakproof lids
  • Made out of BPA-free plastic
  • Might crack easily if dropped
Best for Organizing
AOZITA 16-Pack Plastic Mason Jar Lid

Aozita 16-Pack Plastic Mason Jar Lid

Pros Cons
  • Fits wide- and regular-mouth jars
  • Comes in a variety of colors
  • Leakproof and dishwasher-safe
  • Gaskets may be hard to install
Most Durable
Masontops Multi-Top Flip Cap Mason Jar Lid

Masontops Multi-Top Flip Cap Mason Jar Lid

Pros Cons
  • Leakproof and built to last
  • Serves multiple uses
  • BPA-free and dishwasher-safe
  • Lid can be difficult to remove

FAQs

Are mason jar lids reusable?
While the bands on mason jar lids can be reused, the flat lids should not be reused for canning purposes because the sealing compound can decompose over time, making it less likely to seal properly. However, if the lid is not damaged and you're using the jar for storage rather than preservation purposes, you can reuse the lid.
How do I clean my mason jar lid?
Some mason jar lids can be washed by hand or placed in the dishwasher. However, metal mason jar lids should not be washed in the dishwasher. Otherwise, the lids will become worn down by the detergents over time. Another possibility is that the lids will rust. That's why it is best to handwash metal lids for the best results.
Why isn't my mason jar lid sealing properly?
If your lid doesn't seal correctly, check for any damage or deformities. Debris and residue on the jar's rim or the lid's sealing compound might prevent the lid from sealing properly. Consider replacing the lid if you frequently experience sealing issues.
Are mason jar lids microwave-safe?
Metal mason jar lids are not microwave-safe, so they should never be put in the microwave. Some plastic mason jar lids are microwave-safe, but you'll need to double-check the manufacturer's instructions before doing so.
Can mason jar lids be recycled?
Most metal mason jar lids are recyclable. Meanwhile, plastic mason jar lids should be checked for local recycling guidelines. Some recycling facilities accept them, but whether or not they will is going to vary depending on the area and the type of plastic in question.