Our content is meticulously curated through independent research, testing, reviews, and AI-driven recommendations, all designed to present you with the finest product choices. When you make a purchase through our links, it could result in us earning a commission.

Last Updated:

With one of the best casserole dishes of 2024, you can trust that your food will taste like a professional chef made it for you! To guide you as you shop for casserole dishes, we made this buying guide, and we’re starting the list off with none other than the FineDine Superior Glass Casserole Dish.

A casserole dish is an absolute must when it comes to making your favorite comfort meal. You can use it for lasagna, casseroles, enchiladas, mac and cheese, or even desserts of all kinds. However, the quality of the food you make will depend on which casserole dish you choose.

The Best Casserole Dish: Buying Guide

Casserole dishes might be pricey, but the greatest ones will last a lifetime. If you want to splurge, get one that works on both the stovetop and the oven, and one that looks nice enough to serve right away. You'll need to consider what you'll cook or bake, as well as your preferred style. This helpful buying guide will assist you in choosing the finest casserole dishes!

Who Should Buy Casserole Dishes?

A casserole dish is essential for almost every cook since it can be used for everything, from quick weekday dinners to refined veggie gratin. This dish can be your ultimate choice for candied sweet potatoes, pasta, or a Sunday roast with veggies.

Those who don't have the right size

Casserole dishes are available in several styles, including rectangular, spherical, oval, and square, with capacities ranging from 1 to about 6 quarts. It's a good idea to keep a variety of sizes on board because several recipes call for different-sized dishes. However, the most conventional and flexible dish is the typical rectangular 13-by-9-inches dish since the size is ideal for entrées such as quesadillas and baked goods. Although oval and circular dishes are attractive for aesthetic purposes, they are not functional for cooking foods that carry less food than their squared counterparts.

Those who don't have the right type

Consider investing in a ceramic or glass dish if you only have a metal 13-by-9-inch baking pan. To prevent curdling, burning, or drying, choose a pot that transmits heat more slowly while cooking typical casserole ingredients. When it comes to cooking acidic foods, ceramic, crystal, or lacquered cast-iron dishes are non-reactive, unlike aluminum pans.

Those who don't have a boiler-safe dish

Casserole dishes aren't always necessary, as long as you already have a suitable rectangular dish. Nonetheless, if you detest the shape of your dish or consider its grips to be clunky, you should invest in top-quality casserole dishes. Those who don't have broiler-safe dishes should invest in stoneware or cast-iron dishes that you can use to toast the crumbs on top.

What Common Materials Are Used To Make Casserole Dishes?

Glass

You can closely check heating around the casserole's edges and base with a simple, inexpensive glass casserole dish. However, shocking temperature fluctuations, such as those experienced when moving a glass from the refrigerator to the oven, can cause it to snap or even break. Glass, of course, isn't the only material to experience this problem as it happens with ceramic dishes as well.

Ceramic

Stoneware and porcelain are the standard ceramics used to manufacture casserole dishes. Fired between 2,150 and 2,300 degrees Fahrenheit, stoneware is a durable clay product that is usually impermeable. The bottoms of stoneware casseroles can be glazed or unglazed, while the contents are usually glazed. On the other hand, fired at a greater temperature than stoneware, porcelain may reach temperatures as high as 2,600 degrees Fahrenheit. It is nonporous and inherently nonstick. However, it is more prone to breakage.

Cast-iron

Because of its weight, cast-iron is noted for its heat holding and browning capabilities. Other materials, such as stainless steel or glass, cannot withstand direct heat, such as that used in stovetop cooking. However, they aren't very common.

Which Type of Handle Design Should You Prefer?

Tab-style handle

A tab-style handle is one that is a substantial extension of the dish itself; this is the most common type of handle. Some casserole dishes feature short, snappy tab handles, while others have grips that reach virtually the whole width of the dish. However, we discovered that the handle's length did not matter nearly as much as the width. Additionally, tab-style handles that are less than an inch broad are more difficult to grip while using oven mitts.

Looped handle

Casserole dishes with half-moon-shaped handles that are wrapped around the dish are more comfortable to grip than dishes with table-style handles. Although these handles have a 1.25-inch aperture, they stick out and are easy to grip, especially when wearing thick oven mitts.

How To Choose a Casserole Dish?

Weight

A casserole dish's ideal size and shape are determined by the number of people it will serve and the kind of meals you plan to prepare. The 9-by-13-inch casserole plates usually have 3- to 5-quart capacity and are the ideal size for a regular recipe. Casserole dishes may look identical in size, but the actual weight of each dish is significantly different. The largest dish weighs a staggering 11 lbs, making it difficult to move it around the kitchen, put it into or out of the oven, and wash it in the sink. Casserole plates that weigh less than 5 pounds when empty are the best choice.

Depth

Depth also played an important part in deciding how effectively the casserole dish cooked the food and how convenient it was to use. Because most casserole dishes are not too shallow or too deep, they spread the heat evenly to cook the meal perfectly. A dish that is 2.5 to 2.75 inches deep works best since it is both deep enough to keep food from being squashed by the oven mitt yet shallow enough to permit adequate browning.

Lids

Having a cover on a casserole is helpful if you need to keep it warm for a longer period, such as for breakfast or potluck. Lids are a big selling factor because most casserole dishes don't have them. Ceramic casserole dishes with glass or ceramic can keep a freshly baked casserole hot for hours and is excellent for moving the dish from one place to another. When it comes to transporting and storing leftovers, plastic lids can be used, but they are not oven-safe. Having said that, if you're not taking your mac and cheese or baked meatballs on the road, a cover may not be necessary at all.

Top Picks

  • Best Overall: Finedine Superior Glass Casserole Dish
  • Best Pick: Lodge Three-Quart Casserole Dish
  • Best Set For Beginners: Libbey Baker's Basics Three-Piece Casserole Dish
  • Affordable Choice: Anchor Hocking Two-Quart Casserole Dish
  • Most Durable: Moss & Stone Basics Three-Piece Casserole Dish
  • Also Consider: Simax Round Glass Casserole Dish

Reviews

Best Overall
finedine superior glass casserole dish

Finedine Superior Glass Casserole Dish

Pros Cons
  • Crafted from high-quality borosilicate glass 
  • Generous capacity with versatile designs
  • Aesthetic and functional lid 
  • Makes handling and maneuvering slightly more challenging 
Best Pick
lodge three-quart casserole dish

Lodge Three-Quart Casserole Dish

Pros Cons
  • Stainless steel knobs for excellent grip
  • Unmatched heat retention and dispersion
  • Non-reactive glass surface
  • The enamel coating will chip off if you don't use and clean it as per the manufacturer's instructions.
Best Set for Beginners
libbey baker's basics three-piece casserole dish

Libbey Baker's Basics Three-Piece Casserole Dish

Pros Cons
  • Etched dimensions on handles for easy identification
  • Comes with three transparent lids
  • Can be put in the top rack of the dishwasher
  • The lids can be sturdier and thicker
Affordable Choice
anchor hocking two-quart casserole dish

Anchor Hocking Two-Quart Casserole Dish

Pros Cons
  • High-temperature bearing capacity
  • Can be used in fridge, freezer, microwave, oven, and tabletop
  • BPA-free glass to keep items healthy
  • The dish isn't backed by a warranty
Most Durable
moss & stone basics three-piece casserole dish

Moss & Stone Basics Three-Piece Casserole Dish

Pros Cons
  • Harder and more durable than regular glass
  • Ergonomic handles for better grip
  • Comes with a glass lid
  • The shape isn't a perfect oval but works well for all your cooking needs
Also Consider
simax round glass casserole dish

Simax Round Glass Casserole Dish

Pros Cons
  • High thermal shock-resistant construction
  • Temperatures bearing capacity between 542° and -40° F
  • Holds 1 quart of food
  • A bit expensive compared to other alternatives

FAQs

Are Dutch ovens and casserole dishes the same thing?
No, Dutch ovens and casserole dishes are not the same thing. Dutch ovens have strong walls and narrow tops while casserole dishes are big and shallow skillets or pans.
In what ways might shallow casserole dishes be used?
Shallow casserole dishes are an ideal option for one-pot dinners. They can also be used to bake biscuits, bruschetta, and cakes thanks to the wide base of the pan.
Do casserole dishes have covers?
It is possible to find casserole dishes with either ceramic or plastic covers. Casserole dishes with covers are excellent when you need to transport your food. However, be mindful that not every casserole dish comes with a lid.