-
Our content is meticulously curated through independent research, testing, reviews, and AI-driven recommendations, all designed to present you with the finest product choices. When you make a purchase through our links, it could result in us earning a commission.
The Best Cookie Mixes of 2024
From decadent double chocolate to zesty lemon burst, the best cookie mixes cater to every palate
Have you ever been disappointed by a cookie mix that looked promising on the box but tasted like cardboard? It's frustrating when you want delicious, quick cookies but end up with something that neither tastes good nor simplifies your baking.
The best cookie mix should be quick to make and, most importantly—taste delicious. There's no need for a pantry full of extras; just add a couple of common kitchen staples, stir, and bake. This is what you’ll get with the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix, our best overall cookie mix. In minutes, you'll pull perfectly golden, deliciously chewy cookies out of the oven—cookies that actually taste like they were made from scratch by a skilled baker.
Our Top Picks For Cookie Mixes
View all Contents- Best Cookie Mix FAQs
- Related Articles
5 Best Cookie Mixes of 2024
Best Overall
The Betty Crocker Cookie Mix has a delicious recipe that lets you make cookies quickly. It has a simple formula, allowing you to bake without having ingredients and flour all over the kitchen. Moreover, this pick needs a few readily available ingredients at home to make yummy cookies.
Each box contains nine individual cookie mix packs that make 12 cookies each, which are enough to enjoy after dinner throughout the week. Further, it comes in chocolate chip and sugar cookie flavors. Most noteworthy, the ingredients are super rich in flavor, ensuring you please your cravings and sweet tooth with each bite. If you’re looking for a quality, affordable cookie mix, this is the best cookie mix for you. We voted this mix best overall for its yummy flavor options, customer reviews, and affordability.
Pros
- Quick and easy to prepare
- Makes soft, chewy chocolate chip cookies
- Pack of 9 offers great value
- Suitable for vegetarians
Cons
- Not suitable for people allergic to dairy and soy
Runner-up
If you’re looking for a way to entertain many guests, the Krusteaz Cookie Mix is perfect. It comes in four flavors: triple chocolate chip, sugar cookie, double peanut butter, and snickerdoodle flavors, so you can pick something everyone likes.
In addition, the mix boasts a simple 15-minute recipe. Moreover, the mix contains natural ingredients, no preservatives, and real chocolate chunks, providing a satisfying yet healthy treat. We ranked it #2 on our list for its yummy flavors and high star rating. So, if you looooove chocolate, this is the best cookie mix for you. Lastly, you get 12 boxes in this package, making it easy for you to make cookies whenever you need them.
Pros
- Contains three types of chocolate chunks
- No artificial flavors or preservatives
- Easy to prepare in under 15 minutes
- Customize with add-ins like peanut butter
Cons
- At the time of writing, we couldn’t find a noteworthy con for this mix (4.7-star rating)
Complete Baking Kit
If you want to add a little more creativity and flair to your baking routine, add the Duncan Hines Cookie Mix to the list. It’s a complete kit including everything from cookie dough to flavors and add-ons, allowing you to have a fun baking experience.
Moreover, this mix is designed for families to enjoy baking and bond together. The package comes with directions to bake so you know your cookies will look like the cookies on the box. Likewise, the mix comes in different flavors like cookie dough, fruity pebbles, cookies & cream, salted caramel, and smores brownies. If you like cookie dough, this is the best cookie mix for you.
Pros
- Includes mix, filling, and sprinkles
- Easy-to-follow instructions
- Convenient all-in-one kit
- Ideal for family baking activities
Cons
- Not everyone likes the flavor of cookie dough (filling)
Best Gluten-Free Mix
When it comes to creating unique flavors, Pamela’s Products Cookie Mix stands out. It comes in a 13.6-ounce bag that allows you to bake cookies for the whole family. It includes all-organic, natural chocolate chunks and non-dairy, gluten-free ingredients.
Furthermore, the ingredients are wheat-free, keeping any dietary requirements under consideration. Likewise, it boasts a simple formula, requiring only two ingredients to create delicious cookies or desserts. If you’re looking for a gluten-free cookie mix, this could be the best cookie mix for you. What’s more, you can grab this mix in different sizes depending on your needs.
Pros
- Gluten-free for sensitive diets
- Contains no dairy, suitable for vegans
- Convenient, easy-to-use mix
- Rich chocolate chunk flavor
Cons
- Not many cookie mix flavor options available
Best for Keto
The Mr. Tortilla Cookie Mix is a guiltless sugar-free indulgence for people who want to satisfy their cravings without consuming sugar. The mix contains unsweetened cocoa butter and chocolate that delivers a divine flavor in each bite. It uses erythritol and stevia that satisfy your sweet tooth.
Moreover, despite bursting with flavors, it’s loaded with good fats and zero grains, making it a suitable option for people on vegan and keto-friendly diets. Further, the mix is so simple that it requires no baking skills. Lastly, it’s low in carbs, encouraging you to stay on top of a healthy lifestyle. If you follow a keto diet, this could be the best cookie mix for you.
Pros
- Only 1 net carb per cookie
- Sugar-free with natural sweeteners
- Vegan and keto-friendly recipe
- No advanced baking skills required
Cons
- Not everyone likes the flavor
Choosing the Best Cookie Mix: A User's Guide
You Know How Popular a Cookie Mix Is Based on Customer Reviews
You’re on a web page, staring at cookie mix options, each promising the tastiest, chewiest, most delicious cookies imaginable. But how can you really tell if it’s the best cookie mix? It’s frustrating to buy a mix only to end up with cookies that are too crumbly, too dry, or just plain bland.
And it’s not just about wasting money—though that stings too—it’s about the time and effort you invest in baking.
This is where customer reviews come into their own. Reviews give you the inside scoop from people just like you who have already used the mix and seen the results. They’re the taste testers for the mix you’re considering to buy.
This is what happy customers had to say about the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix:
“I love that my family loves this, and I was able to order in bulk. I will be ordering more very soon [because] they are gone from the cookie jar real fast!! Highly recommended. Very easy to prepare, and they’re delicious!” -Mariela
And another thrilled customer shared the following:
“So easy to whip up a batch of cookies from scratch. Only water and a half stick of soft butter [are] needed. You will have cookies in 10 minutes!” -Luvubul
What You Need to Consider Before Buying a Cookie Mix
1. Flavor
The first thing to consider is the “type” of cookie you are looking to make. Are you a chocolate chip person, or does your choice of cookies revolve around nuts? It’s essential to look for something that you like and is ideal for the occasion. For instance, kids mainly prefer something with chocolate or other variants of fillings. Moreover, the best cookie mix will come in many flavors.
2. Allergens and Additives
Are you allergic to anything? When choosing the best cookie mix, check for allergens like nuts, gluten, dairy, eggs, and soy. Also, look for any additives such as preservatives or artificial flavors. Choose mixes with clear allergen labeling and fewer synthetic ingredients.
3. Quantity
Do you want to make a small batch of cookies or a large batch? Either way, it’s essential to consider the quantity before purchase. One box isn’t enough to feed a big group of people. The best cookie mix should come in a variety of box sizes.
4. Dietary Requirements
If you’re vegan or following a certain type of diet, such as keto, you’ll want to look at the ingredients list carefully.
5. Reputable Brand and Customer Reviews
Usually, well-known brands make the best cookie mixes. And, as I’ve said before, customer reviews speak volumes. Are the customers who’ve bought the cookie mix you’re considering happy with the taste of the cookies?
Moreover, consider complementing the best cookie mix you purchase with a quality cooling rack and silicone baking mat.
3 Tips for Using a Cookie Mix
- Adjust the texture: for chewier cookies, bake them a little less than instructed at a slightly lower temperature. For crispier cookies, extend the baking time slightly at the temperature recommended on the package.
- Upgrade the fats: substituting melted butter for oil can enhance flavor, but you can also consider browning the butter first for a nutty, rich dimension. Another option is to use coconut oil for a slight coconut flavor.
- Rest the prepared mix: after mixing your batter, let it rest for 10 to 20 minutes before baking. This allows the dry ingredients to fully hydrate and can improve the texture and flavor consistency of the cookies.
The Best Cookie Mix Saves You Heaps of Time
No more measuring multiple ingredients. No more following complicated recipes that don’t always turn out right. With the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix, you get consistent quality and taste, batch after batch, giving you more moments to enjoy with family and friends instead of fussing in the kitchen.
So, why settle for bland cookies when you can make amazing ones every time? With the best cookie mix—the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix—you’re not just baking; you’re making joyous memories, one yummy cookie at a time.
Best Cookie Mix FAQs
What is the shelf life of cookie mix?
If stored under proper conditions and in air-tight jars, a cookie mix powder can last for over six months.
Can I make other desserts with cookie mix?
You can get creative with the best cookie mix and make desserts that feature cookie dough as the base ingredient.
Are there cookie mix options for people on a diet?
Yes, you can find healthier options like dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan.
What is the best cookie mix?
The best cookie mix for you depends on your needs and preferences. The Betty Crocker Cookie Mix is ideal for those seeking variety and ease, offering chocolate chip and sugar cookie flavors in a pack of nine that each make 12 cookies. On the other hand, the Krusteaz Cookie Mix is perfect for entertaining many guests, with four flavors and a package of 12 boxes, each promising natural ingredients and quick preparation times.
What is the highest-rated cookie mix?
Both the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix and the Krusteaz Cookie Mix have a high star rating, indicating strong customer satisfaction for each.
What do customers say about the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix?
Customers are highly satisfied with the Betty Crocker Cookie Mix, praising it for its ease of preparation and delicious results. Many appreciate the convenience of being able to quickly whip up cookies, noting that only minimal additional ingredients are needed. Positive feedback often highlights the quick baking time and the mix's ability to consistently produce tasty cookies, making it a favorite for both its quality and convenience.
Can you save time by using a cookie mix?
Yes, you can definitely save time by using a cookie mix. The best cookie mix usually only requires a few additional ingredients and minimal prep time. This means you can have cookies ready to go in the oven in just a few minutes, much faster than measuring out and mixing all the individual ingredients from scratch.
