The Best Cookie Stamps of 2024

The Best Cookie Stamps: A Buyer’s Guide

Below are some of the features and factors we encourage you to look for when shopping for the perfect cookie stamp set.

What To Consider When Shopping For the Best Cookie Stamps

Material

The material that a cookie stamp is made from is one of the most important things that you should consider before you purchase one. This is because the material not only determines whether the cookie stamp is safe to use or not but also how well it will perform.

When it comes to high-quality cookie cutters, metal and plastic are the two most popular options. Focusing on metal cookie cutters, stamps made out of copper, stainless steel, and aluminum are the three best options. Some cookie cutters come with handles, too, making them easier to hold and transport.

If you are looking for flexible cookie cutters that are easy to wash, then tin cutters are an ideal option for you. On the other hand, aluminum cookie cutters are more flexible and durable. Plus, they are also very budget-friendly, so they’re quite a popular choice. That said, for the most durable cookie stamp option on the market,, you can’t find anything better than stainless steel cutters.

Then, while copper cookie cutters are on the more costly side of things, they are very durable, and they won’t ever get bent out of shape. These types of cutters also feature quite detailed and decorative designs, so creative bakers with a lot of ideas should give these cookie stamps a try.

If you are looking for inexpensive cookie cutters, then plastic stamps are a great option. Not only are they affordable but they also come in a lot of fun designs. Since plastic cookie stamps have soft edges, they are typically a lot easier to work with. Just make sure plastic cookie stamps are BPA-free and made from food-grade materials before buying them.

Versatility

To make the most out of your cookie stamps, look for cutters that are versatile. A lot of them are originally made for the sole purpose of cutting cookies into various shapes, but you can also find some that are multi-purposed. This makes them suitable for fondants, pastries, cakes, and playdough.

It’s also smart to look for versatility in terms of the cookie cutter’s design. For instance, cookie stamps that include numbers or letters can be used to write various, messages such as “happy birthday” or “congratulations.”

Storage

To ensure that your cookie stamps last for as long as possible without sustaining much damage, you’ll need to store them properly. For instance, packing plastic cookie cutters in the same place as steel cutters can cause damage to the plastic ones.

Similarly, packing steel and copper cutters together in a tight space can ruin the shape of the two different types of cookie cutters. That’s why it is important that you store different cookie cutters separately. The best ideal way to store cookie stamps is to store each type in separate storage bags.

Cleaning

Cleaning cookie stamps can be a hassle, and that’s why the best cookie stamps on the market are dishwasher-safe. Generally speaking, plastic and silicone cookie stamps are easier to wash than steel and copper ones.

However, naturally, the ease of cleaning will depend on the design as well. Intricate designs that come with a lot of little detailing might take longer to clean than simple ones, like symbols, letters, and various shapes.

Durability

If you don’t want to accidentally purchase cookie stamps that one end up lasting about a year, then you should look for ones made from sturdy materials. In most cases, stainless steel and copper are the most durable materials, meaning they won’t break or bend easily. However, you can also find high-quality plastic cookie stamps that don’t compromise in terms of durability.

Design and shape

Cookie stamps come in many different shapes and designs. From round stamps to star-shaped stamps, there are countless options that you can choose from. Regardless of whether you are looking for a cookie stamp in the shape of a butterfly, caterpillar, star, or cat, there are cookie stamps in nearly every shape you could possibly imagine.

Size

Cookie stamps come in all different sizes. Naturally, for a bite-sized cookie, you will need a small stamp. Likewise, for large cookies, you’ll need big cookie stamps. If you think you’ll make cookies of all different sizes, consider opting for a cookie-cutter set that comes with stamps of all sizes.

Non-stick

Peeling cookie dough off of cookie stamps can be very a time-consuming and frustrating process. To minimize your frustration, prioritize non-stick cookie stamps. Not only are they easier to clean but they are also very convenient because you won’t have to deal with cookies that don’t come out the way you wanted them to just because the stamp stuck to the dough. Essentially, non-stick cookie cutters ensure that the final product comes out as desired.