-
Our content is meticulously curated through independent research, testing, reviews, and AI-driven recommendations, all designed to present you with the finest product choices. When you make a purchase through our links, it could result in us earning a commission.
The Best Yogurt Maker of 2024
Yogurt is a delicious source of probiotics, proteins, vitamins and minerals, and many other nutrients. It's so delicious that you either eat it straight out of the refrigerator or make a yogurt cereal bowl for breakfast! However, preparing this frozen dessert at home can be difficult if you're trying the traditional fermentation method. Luckily for us, yogurt makers make it possible to make delectable frozen deserts right at home with little effort. We've tested the best yogurt makers of 2024 and can safely say that the Cuisinart Automatic Frozen Yogurt Maker is the best of its kind on the market! Our other recommendations are just as good, so get started on making your homemade yogurt!
Our Top Picks For Yogurt Makers
View all ContentsThe Best Yogurt Makers
Best Overall
The Cuisinart Automatic Frozen Yogurt Maker is fully automatic to help you prepare frozen yogurt, sorbets, and ice creams within twenty-five minutes only. Its brushed stainless steel housing is highly durable and protects the internal hardware units from any damage. This yogurt maker sports a heavy-duty motor that will churn your dessert mix at high speed to prepare a delicious frozen dessert faster. Besides that, it has a large ingredient spout that will allow you to pour all the ingredients quickly. As its freezer bowl has double insulation, no heat exchange will occur, and the dessert will stay frozen for a longer time. In addition, you won’t have to whip the mixture manually as the appliance has an automatic paddle mixer. All of these features make this our best overall pick!
Pros
- Makes 2 quarts of frozen dessert at once
- BPA-free plastic material
Cons
- Not affordable for everyone
Value For Money
If you are looking for a cheaper yogurt maker, then go for the Euro Cuisine Yogurt Maker. It has a bowl-like shape where you will place the yogurt-filled jars. As the pack comes with seven jars, each measuring about 6 ounces, you can effortlessly make natural creamy yogurt or flavored ones. They’re also made from BPA-free material so that yogurt can stay fresh in the refrigerator for ten days maximum. This yogurt maker has a clear, transparent lid that you need to put on once you have placed all seven jars inside. You can easily set a timer scale marked at its side (1 hour to 9 hours) by rotating the cover lid. Additionally, it comes with an on/off switch and an indicator light to let you know if the appliance is working or not.
Pros
- Allows you to experiment with different flavors
- Dishwasher-safe
Cons
- Not suitable for ice creams and sorbets
Maximum Capacity
The Hatrigo Greek Yogurt Make has a total capacity of 6 quarts so that you can get a vast amount of the frozen dessert in a single batch. Its outer body and lid comprise BPA-free plastic, while the yogurt strainer is stainless steel. Using this ultra-fine strainer with a superior mesh design will help you strain water from plain yogurt, almond milk mix, cheese, and more. Therefore, there is no need to use a muslin cloth to drain the excess liquid from these dairy products. Once the Greek yogurt is ready, take the filter and invert it to release the desert block. You can store it in jars and refrigerate it for a couple of days. Even though it has a huge capacity, its design is compact so that you can easily store the filter in the freezer.
Pros
- With a BPA-free construction
- Helps drain excess water from dairy product
Cons
- Cleaning the stainless steel strainer is challenging
Best Design
With the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker, there’s a large, cylindrical base component inside where the buckets, strainer, and other parts can be stacked easily. Therefore, you won’t have to worry about storage space over your kitchen countertop or inside the cabinet. After assembling all the parts, add milk of your choice and a tiny amount of yogurt inside the strainer bucket and close the lid. There is a control regulator at the front with a power on/off switch, a ‘set’ button, and two additional buttons (+/-) for altering the set time. It will take approximately eight to ten hours to strain all the milk and yogurt mix liquid and form creamy, smooth Greek yogurt. In addition, you will get a recipe book in the form of a turning dial to easily make different types of Greek yogurt.
Pros
- Non-electric parts are easy to clean
- Makes 2 Quarts of Greek yogurt at once
Cons
- Not ideal for huge quantities of yogurt
Best Add-ons
The Bear 2-In-1 Yogurt Maker has eight cylindrical ceramic mugs and two borosilicate glass jars. These two glass jars can be sealed easily by simply pressing down the lid. So, you won’t have any problem experimenting with different yogurt flavors. It has an adjustable temperature range (96 degrees Fahrenheit to 114-degrees Fahrenheit) and a timer (20 hours maximum) so that you can make the perfect yogurt. It also has a touchscreen control panel that will help you set temperature and timer values with more precision and accuracy and choose the required program mode for fresh and plant yogurt. It also has an LED screen that displays temperature values. Once the time is over, and yogurt is ready, the product will shut off automatically with a beep sound.
Pros
- Will save more energy owing to the auto shut-off feature
- Allows you to make yogurt with flavors effortlessly
Cons
- Has ceramic cups with less capacity as compared to the glass jars
Best Yogurt Makers Buying Guide
Most people like to enjoy a cup of frozen yogurt or eat a bowl of Greek yogurt with their favorite fruits and cereals. That’s why a yogurt maker will make you appreciate the dessert even more considering the complicated process to make yogurt. Luckily, we no longer have to go through the traditional fermentation process thanks to all the yogurt makers on the market. Choosing the best out of them is not easy. as it’s a cumbersome process, which is why we have prepared a complete buying guide for you!
The Key Factors to Consider When Choosing the Best Yogurt Maker
Type
There are two types of yogurt makers in the market that can be categorized based on their design. Some yogurt makers have a large-sized bowl where you pour the milk and yogurt mix. These products will make a large yogurt chunk. But if you want to prepare yogurt with different flavors or in small quantities, go for a product that comes in cups or jars. You need to put the mixture in these small jars and keep them inside the main yogurt maker. Therefore, you will separate jars of the frozen dessert for everyone in the family.
Number of cups/jars
If you have chosen a product with cups or jars, you need to pay attention to the number of containers. For a small family of three members maximum, you can have a product with five to six yogurt cups or jars. But if you want to serve more people with the dessert, go for a yogurt maker that has eight to ten cups or jars.
Strainer
In some yogurt makers, you will find a filter. This component is essential in preparing Greek yogurt from plain yogurt, cheese from curdled milk, etc. The strainer will help drain all the liquid content from the food item without using a muslin cloth.
Capacity
If you do not decide on the suitable capacity of the yogurt maker, you may end up having a product that won’t be able to make enough dessert to feed everyone. Usually, the total capacity of this kitchen appliance varies between 1.31 Quarts to 6 Quarts. For preparing a vast block of frozen desserts, go for a product with a capacity of 5 Quarts to 6 Quarts in whole. On the other hand, if you have chosen a yogurt maker with cups or jars, make sure that the individual container has enough capacity for preparing the dessert in a generous portion. These products have an overall capacity of 1.31 Quarts to 3 Quarts.
Material
The yogurt makers have stainless steel or thick plastic exterior body. Stainless steel is known for its high durability and tensile strength to protect all the product’s hardware units. On the contrary, plastic yogurt makers are light and easier to handle. If your chosen yogurt maker has a strainer, make sure it is made from stainless steel mesh so that the component can last for a long time. Most times, the cups that come with the yogurt maker comprise BPA-free plastic material. However, in a few products, you will have borosilicate glass jars and ceramic mugs that are highly durable and non-toxic.
Temperature adjustability
Some yogurt makers have adjustable temperature controls to help you set the right temperature for transforming the milk mixture into yogurt. For example, you have bought a product with adjustable temperature control. It will help you quickly increase or decrease the value within the configured range like 96 degrees Fahrenheit to 114 degrees Fahrenheit.
Timer
Another essential factor you have to consider while buying the yogurt maker is the timer options. Some products have multiple timer settings, while a few can allow you to set a time of 20 hours maximum. If you want to serve normal yogurt, go for a product with lesser timer settings. On the contrary, if you like to make smooth, soft, and fluffy Greek yogurt with different flavors, you should choose a product with a higher timer value. In a few products, the auto shut-off feature will produce a beep sound once the time is over.
LED display
In some yogurt makers, there is an LED display screen that shows the current temperature value and time. It will allow you to adjust both these parameters with precision and accuracy so that you can make the best yogurts with no hassle.
Storage
The ease of storing the yogurt maker will depend on the size of the product. Some yogurt makers have a tall, slender, and cylindrical body that you can keep in a corner on your kitchen countertop or inside the cabinet. However, the products with a flat, circular, or rectangular shape will occupy a lot of space.
The Average Cost of a Yogurt Maker
The yogurt makers have a price range starting from $27.99 to $87.95. If your product is stainless steel, it will be higher priced than those manufactured from plastic. Similarly, a yogurt maker with an adjustable temperature and timer will cost more than regular products.
How to Use a Yogurt Maker
If you don’t know how to use a yogurt maker, you can follow these steps to get the best result.
- First, boil the milk to a specific temperature and cool it down in an ice bath.
- Once the milk is lukewarm, mix a small portion of the yogurt and stir it.
Pour this mixture into the yogurt maker or the cups and jars. - Close the lid cover and set the timer and temperature.
- Leave the arrangement for the specified time without disturbing it or opening the lid.
How to Liven Up Plain Yogurt
You can add different flavors to the yogurt mix to make the dessert more delicious and exciting. For example, you can make blueberry yogurt, vanilla yogurt, and so on. Apart from this, you can also add small pieces of fruit into the milk mixture, and then pour the entire content inside the yogurt maker.
People Also Asked
Can I make ice creams and sorbets with the yogurt maker?
All the yogurt makers won't allow you to make ice creams and sorbets. Therefore, you have to choose a product having an automated turning paddle that can churn the ice cream or sorbet mixture and freeze it simultaneously.
How can I know whether my yogurt maker is on?
Once you switch on the yogurt maker, the indicator light will glow, alerting you that the appliance is active and ready to make yogurt.
What type of milk should I use with the yogurt maker to make the dessert?
You can use any milk with the yogurt makers. But make sure to mix regular yogurt with the milk before pouring it inside the product.
